TL;DR: Undercroft is a basement speakeasy-style bar at 201 NW A St., Bentonville, housed in a Gothic Revival church building completed in January 1905 (undercroftbar.com/hoursandlocation; Vintage Bentonville, accessed August 2026).
Undercroft Hours and Location Details
Undercroft operates as a basement speakeasy-style bar located at 201 NW A St., Bentonville, AR, phone 479-445-6065, directly beneath The Preacher's Son restaurant (undercroftbar.com/hoursandlocation, accessed August 2026). Undercroft is the kind of bar you have to know to look for — there's no street-level signage announcing it, only a staircase down from the restaurant above. It is closed Mondays and Sundays, open Tuesday through Thursday from 5 to 11 p.m., and Friday and Saturday from 5 p.m. to midnight (undercroftbar.com/hoursandlocation, accessed August 2026).
Prospective guests should verify these hours before arriving, as restaurant and bar schedules can change. Discover Bentonville, Arkansas through this kind of below-street-level spot, tucked beneath a much more visible restaurant.
Gothic Revival Church Building History
The structure now occupied by Undercroft and The Preacher's Son was originally built as Bentonville's First Christian Church, a Gothic Revival building completed in January 1905, featuring a furnace heater, electric lights, oak pews and art glass windows (Vintage Bentonville, accessed August 2026; Shears Adkins Rockmore architects, accessed August 2026). Undercroft, The Preacher's Son and rooftop bar Celeste are all housed in the same restored building today (thepreachersson.com, accessed August 2026; The Indigo Road Hospitality Group, accessed August 2026). Stacking three distinct concepts — a below-ground speakeasy, a restaurant in the former sanctuary, and a rooftop bar — inside one building is an unusual way to fill a historic structure, and it means a single visit downtown can move from ground level to rooftop and back to basement without leaving the block.
First Christian Church has since relocated to 807 SE 14th Street, Bentonville, AR, and its former sanctuary was converted into what is now The Preacher's Son, with Undercroft occupying the basement beneath it (Vintage Bentonville, accessed August 2026). It's an unusual pairing — a 120-year-old sanctuary now hosting a speakeasy, a restaurant and a rooftop bar under one roof — and one of downtown Bentonville's clearer examples of an older building finding a second life rather than being torn down.
Downtown Walkability
Undercroft sits close enough to the Square that its block shares the same walkability advantage as the rest of the historic core: a Square-adjacent address at 211 S Main St carries a Walk Score of 83 ("Very Walkable") and a Bike Score of 84 ("Very Bikeable"), well above the citywide average Walk Score of 24 for Bentonville overall (Walk Score, accessed August 2026).
If you're considering a move near downtown Bentonville, you can list your home with us.
Bentonville Market Snapshot
Bentonville had an estimated population of 63,057 as of July 1, 2025 (U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts). As of July 2026, the median home sale price was $415,000, with 766 active listings representing 2.64 months of inventory supply (Houzeo) — a market with meaningful buyer competition but not extreme scarcity. A downtown that supports a hidden basement bar beneath a converted church, alongside a rooftop bar and a full-service restaurant in the same building, is one sign of how much depth Bentonville's dining and nightlife scene has developed over a relatively short span of years.
Working With Mason Capital Group in Bentonville
Mason Capital Group has maintained a presence in Northwest Arkansas for over 30 years, with more than $2.4 billion in cumulative transaction activity. Our office is at 609 SW 8th Street, 6th Floor, Bentonville, AR 72712, and we can be reached at 479-925-3333. Current inventory is on our featured listings page. For anyone weighing a move near downtown, a basement bar operating quietly beneath a converted church — alongside a full restaurant and a rooftop bar in the same building — is a small but telling sign of how much has been packed into a few historic blocks over the past several years, from historic preservation to nightlife variety. Church buildings are not always easy to repurpose given their tall sanctuaries and fixed architectural details, which makes a conversion that stacks a restaurant, a rooftop bar and a hidden basement lounge into one former sanctuary a notable example of what's possible with an older downtown structure.
What are the Undercroft bar hours?
Undercroft is closed Mondays and Sundays, open Tuesday-Thursday 5-11 p.m. and Friday-Saturday 5 p.m.-midnight (undercroftbar.com/hoursandlocation, accessed August 2026).
Where is Undercroft located in Bentonville?
Undercroft is a basement speakeasy-style bar located at 201 NW A St., Bentonville, AR, phone 479-445-6065, directly beneath The Preacher's Son restaurant (undercroftbar.com/hoursandlocation, accessed August 2026).
What is the history of the Undercroft building?
The building housing Undercroft and The Preacher's Son was originally built as Bentonville's First Christian Church, a Gothic Revival structure completed in January 1905 with a furnace heater, electric lights, oak pews and art glass windows (Vintage Bentonville, accessed August 2026; Shears Adkins Rockmore architects, accessed August 2026).
Who operates Undercroft and The Preacher's Son?
Undercroft and The Preacher's Son are both operated by Indigo Road Hospitality Group and share a building with rooftop bar Celeste (thepreachersson.com, accessed August 2026; The Indigo Road Hospitality Group, accessed August 2026).
Is the Undercroft building walkable from downtown?
A downtown Bentonville Square address (211 S Main St) carries a Walk Score of 83 ("Very Walkable") and a Bike Score of 84 ("Very Bikeable"), compared with a citywide average Walk Score of 24 for Bentonville overall (Walk Score, accessed August 2026).