TL;DR: Stone Mill Cafe, founded in Fayetteville in 1997 and now family-run at 2903 S Walton Blvd, Bentonville, serves scratch-made sandwiches, soups and salads with no preservatives (Talk Business & Politics, 2017; stonemillcafebentonville.com, accessed August 2026).
A Family-Run Cafe on South Walton Boulevard
Stone Mill began as Stone Mill Bread & Flour Co. in Fayetteville, founded in May 1997 by Dan and Karen Dantzler (Talk Business & Politics, 2017). Their daughter Dana Comer and her husband Terry Comer opened the Bentonville location at 2903 S Walton Blvd in the Metro Market shopping center in 2017, a 3,100-square-foot space with a drive-through pickup window not offered at the original Fayetteville store (Talk Business & Politics, 2017). Today the Bentonville cafe is at 2903 S Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712 (stonemillcafebentonville.com, accessed August 2026), open Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. and closed Sundays (stonemillcafebentonville.com, accessed August 2026) — hours built around breakfast and lunch rather than dinner service.
Discover Bentonville, Arkansas for more on the independent restaurants and cafes scattered around town.
What's on the Menu
Stone Mill Cafe focuses on scratch-made sandwiches, soups and salads, stating that its recipes and dressings are prepared in-house without preservatives (stonemillcafebentonville.com, accessed August 2026). The restaurant also offers build-your-own sandwiches, letting guests customize a meal rather than choose from a fixed list. Making dressings and recipes from scratch daily is a bigger daily commitment than a shop relying on premade ingredients, and it's part of what has kept regulars coming back over the restaurant's first decade in business.
The sandwich menu includes the Chicken Salad Supreme, the Stone Mill Club, a BLT and BALT, a Reuben, a Cajun Special, and a Spinach & Basil Pesto sandwich, alongside salads such as the Garden Salad, Spring Salad Mix, Chef Salad and Cobb Salad (SinglePlatform menu listing, accessed August 2026). Breakfast items include a Signature Breakfast Sandwich, a breakfast burrito, biscuits and gravy, and a rotating selection of skillets, while soups on the menu include chicken and dumplings, creamy chicken noodle, chicken tortilla and broccoli cheddar (SinglePlatform menu listing, accessed August 2026).
Covering breakfast, lunch and a full soup-and-salad lineup under one roof is more than a typical single-purpose sandwich shop attempts, which is part of why Stone Mill Cafe draws both a morning crowd and a midday lunch crowd on the same day. Running the Bentonville location as a second generation of the same family is a different kind of continuity than a franchise expansion — the recipes and standards trace directly back to the original Fayetteville bakery rather than a corporate playbook.
Neighboring Businesses on South Walton Boulevard
Crisp & Green, a fast-casual healthy restaurant, is at 1401 S. Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712 (crispandgreen.com, accessed August 2026). Hype Coffee, a locally owned coffee shop operating since June 2021, is at 1111 S Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712 (Better Business Bureau, accessed August 2026). Between the three, this stretch of S Walton Blvd covers breakfast, lunch and coffee without requiring a drive across town. A morning visitor could grab coffee from Hype, sit down for a full breakfast skillet at Stone Mill, and come back at lunchtime for a salad at Crisp & Green — three very different kitchens within a few minutes of each other, none of them requiring a reservation or a long wait to get a table. That kind of density is easy to take for granted until comparing it to a neighborhood where breakfast, lunch and coffee each require a separate drive.
Bentonville Market Snapshot
Bentonville had an estimated population of 63,057 as of July 1, 2025 (U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts). As of July 2026, the median home sale price in Bentonville was $415,000, with 766 active listings representing 2.64 months of inventory supply (Houzeo). If you're considering a move to Bentonville, you can list your home with us.
Working With Mason Capital Group in Bentonville
Mason Capital Group has maintained a presence in Northwest Arkansas for over 30 years, with more than $2.4 billion in cumulative transaction activity. Our office is at 609 SW 8th Street, 6th Floor, Bentonville, AR 72712, and we can be reached at 479-925-3333. Current inventory is on our featured listings page.
What are Stone Mill Cafe's operating hours in Bentonville?
Stone Mill Cafe is open Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. and is closed on Sundays (stonemillcafebentonville.com, accessed August 2026).
Where is Stone Mill Cafe located on South Walton Boulevard?
The restaurant is at 2903 S Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712 (stonemillcafebentonville.com, accessed August 2026).
Who founded Stone Mill and when did the Bentonville location open?
Stone Mill began as Stone Mill Bread & Flour Co., founded in Fayetteville in May 1997 by Dan and Karen Dantzler; their daughter Dana Comer and her husband Terry Comer opened the Bentonville location at 2903 S Walton Blvd in the Metro Market shopping center in 2017, a 3,100-square-foot space with a drive-through pickup window (Talk Business & Politics, 2017).
What other dining options are nearby on South Walton Boulevard?
Crisp & Green is at 1401 S. Walton Blvd (crispandgreen.com, accessed August 2026) and Hype Coffee is at 1111 S Walton Blvd, operating since June 2021 (Better Business Bureau, accessed August 2026).
What is the median home sale price in Bentonville?
The median home sale price in Bentonville was $415,000 as of July 2026, with 766 active listings representing 2.64 months of inventory supply (Houzeo).